Today / USA - MLS / Columbus Crew vs New York City FC

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC Prediction— USA - MLS

Matchday 16 ·Wednesday, July 22, 2026, 23:30

Columbus Crew logo
Columbus Crew
PPG 1.57 · HOME
LAST 5
DLLLL
1 – 2
FULL TIME
✓ MODEL PICK HIT · BTTS
New York City FC logo
New York City FC
PPG 1.14 · AWAY
LAST 5
LLDDD

// Model verdict

BTTS 59% chance

Model probability 52.3% vs bookmaker-implied 62.5%.

Poisson scoreline matrix HOME ↓ / AWAY →

01234+ 0 0-08.1%0-18.7%0-24.7%0-31.7%0-4+0.6%1 1-011.6%1-112.5%1-26.7%1-32.4%1-4+0.8%2 2-08.4%2-19.0%2-24.8%2-31.7%2-4+0.6%3 3-04.0%3-14.3%3-22.3%3-30.8%3-4+0.3%4+ 4+-02.0%4+-12.1%4+-21.1%4+-30.4%4+-4+0.1%
Cell shade = scoreline probability LOW HIGH · ▣ FT RESULT

Markets vs the line MODEL / ODDS / EV

MarketModelImpliedOddsEV
Home win 46.0% 50.8% 1.97 -9.4%
Draw 26.6% 27.8% 3.60 -2.5%
Away win 27.4% 28.6% 3.50 -2.5%
Over 2.5 50.0% 58.8% 1.70 -15.0%
Over 3.5 28.7% 35.7% 2.80 -11.8%
BTTS 52.3% 62.5% 1.60 -16.3%
Home O1.5 46.3% 54.1% 1.85 -14.3%
Away O1.5 36.4% 37.7% 2.65 -3.5%

League track record

Based on 110 resolved predictions

1X2 Acc 46%
O2.5 60%
BTTS 64%
Score Hit 48%
ROI -18.9%
Bet Hit 52%

Correct score prediction CORRECT SCORE MODEL

2 – 1 23%CONFIDENCE
✘ MISS — FT 1-2
xG (home)1.4 xG (away)1.1 BTTS prob52.3%

H 46% / xG 1.4-1.1 / O2.5 50% / BTTS 52%

Top 5 Poisson scorelines

#1 1–1 12.5%
#2 0–0 8.1%
#3 1–0 11.6%
#4 2–1 9.0%
#5 2–0 8.4%

Expected goals MODEL xG

Columbus Crew1.4
New York City FC1.1

COMBINED 2.5 xG → O2.5 PROB 50.0% · O3.5 PROB 28.7%

Form & verdict PPG

COLUMBUS CREW · PPG 1.57

NEW YORK CITY FC · PPG 1.14

⚠ LOW CONFIDENCE - ✓ FAIR - Balanced matchup, limited value | No clear value
Chance this pick lands
59%
BALANCED

xG gap +0.36 - no reliable favorite, elevated draw risk

Win probability 1X2

Columbus Crew (H) 46.0%
ODDS 1.97 · IMPLIED 50.8% EV -9.4%
Draw 26.6%
ODDS 3.60 · IMPLIED 27.8% EV -2.5%
New York City FC (A) 27.4%
ODDS 3.50 · IMPLIED 28.6% EV -2.5%

Season Statistics average per match · 21 matches · 2026

Columbus Crew ▾ lower is better New York City FC

Attack

11.4
Shots
11.4
3.8
Shots on target
4.7
4.5
Shots off target
3.8
3.2
Blocked shots
2.9
7.0
Shots inside box
8.1
4.4
Shots outside box
3.3
33.5%
Shooting accuracy
41.2%
36.2%
Goals per shot on target
33.3%
1.38
Goals
1.57
1.17
xG for
1.38

Defence

10.7
Shots faced
12.2
4.9
Shots on target faced
4.8
1.76
Goals conceded
1.35
1.19
xG against
1.42
3.0
Goalkeeper saves
3.4

Control

57.1%
Possession
53.7%
575
Passes
503
506
Accurate passes
427
87.9%
Pass accuracy
85.0%
5.3
Corners
3.5
3.8
Corners faced
4.6
1.9
Offsides
2.7

Discipline

9.9
Fouls
11.7
1.5
Yellow cards
1.8
0.00
Red cards
0.04

Match Preview & Prediction

Columbus Crew face New York City FC in USA - MLS on Wednesday, July 22, 2026. Our Poisson-based model has analysed both teams' form, attack and defence strength to generate the prediction below. The model gives Columbus Crew a 46% chance, the draw 27% and New York City FC 27%, so Columbus Crew are favoured to win. Expected goals are 1.4 for Columbus Crew and 1.1 for New York City FC (2.5 total). The most likely scoreline is 1-1. There is a 50% chance of over 2.5 goals and a 52% chance of both teams scoring. On recent form, Columbus Crew are averaging 1.57 points per game versus 1.14 for New York City FC. The best value bet our model finds is A/O25, with an expected value of +1.5%. This match finished 1-2.

PredictVantage

Free daily football predictions across 240+ leagues. A Poisson-based model analyses team form, attack and defence strength, and live bookmaker odds to surface value bets — updated every day, graded every night.

18+ only. PredictVantage is for entertainment and informational purposes only. All predictions are model-generated and do not guarantee any outcome. Match dates and kick-off times come from third-party data and may change — confirm with official sources before betting. Gambling involves risk — never bet more than you can afford to lose. BeGambleAware.org